Google Reviews
★★★★★
5.0 Rating

Criminal record background checks vs Police record checks

Summary 

This blog explains the key differences between criminal record background checks (DBS) used for UK employment and police record checks (ACRO Police Certificates) typically required for visas and immigration. It covers what each check includes, when they are needed, and how employers and candidates should use them within the background screening process. With practical examples, compliance guidance, and advice on candidate rights, it highlights why choosing the right check is essential for safer recruitment, regulatory compliance, and global mobility.

Introduction

When it comes to vetting candidates, UK employers encounter two terms that sound similar but serve very different purposes: criminal record background checks VS police record checks.

  • Criminal record background checks usually mean DBS checks (or Disclosure Scotland / Access NI in devolved nations) carried out for employment.
  • Police record checks typically refer to a Police Certificate issued by ACRO, often needed for visa and immigration purposes.

Confusing the two can lead to compliance risks, unnecessary delays, or unfair treatment of applicants. This guide breaks down the differences, explains what each type of check reveals, and shows how they fit into the wider background screening process.

 

Employee screening, employee vetting services from Eurocom C.I. | Criminal record background checks vs Police record checks

Simplify checks. Explore our DBS Update Service Checker

Overview of Criminal Record Background Checks

In the UK, criminal background checks are most often carried out through the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).

What is a Criminal Record Background Check?

A criminal record background check confirms whether a candidate has a history of convictions or cautions and is tailored to the level of risk associated with the role.

Types of Criminal Record Checks

  • Basic DBS – shows unspent convictions and conditional cautions.
  • Standard DBS – shows spent and unspent convictions and cautions, unless protected.
  • Enhanced DBS – adds relevant local police information and, where applicable, checks against the barred lists.

Purpose of Criminal Record Checks

These checks support safer recruitment in roles involving children, vulnerable adults, or sensitive data. They also help organisations demonstrate compliance with safeguarding frameworks while respecting the rights of individuals with spent convictions under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act.

From 21 January 2026, self-employed individuals and personal employees who are paid for their roles can apply for their own Enhanced or Enhanced with Barred List(s) DBS checks, where the role is legally eligible. Previously, only a Basic check was available to them directly - a higher-level check needed an employing organisation to apply.

These applications are made through a DBS umbrella body, such as Eurocom CI, which confirms the role's eligibility before submission.

These applications must still be processed through a registered DBS Umbrella Body, such as Eurocom CI, to confirm eligibility and meet safeguarding requirements - but a traditional employer is no longer always required.

Read more about criminal record checks in our blog here.

Overview of Police Record Checks

Unlike DBS checks, police record checks are not generally used for UK employment. They are typically required for immigration and visa applications.

What is a Police Record Check?

A Police Certificate issued by ACRO confirms whether a person has a criminal record in the UK. Many embassies and consulates require this certificate when individuals apply to live, work, or study abroad.

Types of Police Record Checks

  • Police Certificate (ACRO): For immigration or residency applications.
  • Subject Access Request: Allows individuals to see data held on them by UK police, but is not valid for employment.

Purpose of Police Record Checks

The main purpose is to meet foreign government requirements for immigration, rather than employment vetting in the UK.

Key Differences: Criminal Record Background Checks and Police Record Checks

Scope of Checks

  • DBS checks: Tailored to the role, with eligibility rules for Standard and Enhanced.
  • Police certificates: Broad overview of UK criminal records for visa purposes.

National Background Check vs Local Checks

  • DBS Enhanced: Can include information from local police forces where relevant to safeguarding.
  • Police certificates: Draw from central UK police databases only, with no local discretion.

Types of Records Disclosed

Misdemeanor Background Check Considerations

The UK doesn’t use the term misdemeanor. Instead, convictions are classed as summary, either-way, or indictable offences. When dealing with overseas applications, candidates may need to clarify how UK offences align with “misdemeanors” abroad.

Employment Screening Context

Role of Employment Screening Services

Modern employment screening services go beyond criminal record checks, combining:

  • Right-to-work verification
  • Identity checks
  • Employment history verification
  • Overseas criminality checks (when candidates have lived abroad)

How Employers Use Checks

  • Most UK jobs: Basic DBS (or none) depending on the role.
  • Safeguarding roles: Enhanced DBS with barred lists.
  • Overseas mobility: Police certificates for visa applications alongside domestic DBS checks.

Compliance, Fairness, and Candidate Rights

Employers must:

  • Request the appropriate level of DBS check for the role.
  • Respect filtering rules, meaning not all convictions appear.
  • Avoid asking candidates to disclose information that is legally protected.
  • Ensure data handling complies with GDPR and equality law.

Candidates should:

  • Confirm which check applies to their situation.
  • Understand their rights around spent and filtered convictions.
  • Apply for police certificates only when required by immigration authorities.

Future Trends in Background Screening

  • Digital identity services will speed up right-to-work and DBS checks.
  • Global hiring means employers will increasingly combine national background checks with international police certificates.
  • Policy changes in filtering and disclosure law may further protect individuals from unnecessary discrimination.

Conclusion

The difference between criminal record background checks VS police record checks is clear:

  • Criminal record checks (DBS): Used for UK employment, tailored to job role, with legal protections around spent and filtered convictions.
  • Police record checks (ACRO certificates): Used primarily for immigration and visas, not standard recruitment.

For employers: Match the check to the role, follow eligibility rules, and use trusted screening services.
For candidates: Know your rights, be clear on what will show, and only provide the check required.

Need expert support with employment background checks? Speak to Eurocom CI today- drop us an email on info@eurocomci.co.uk.

 

Employee screening, employee vetting services from Eurocom C.I. | Criminal record background checks vs Police record checks

Simplify checks. Explore our DBS Update Service Checker.

Ramya Sehmi - Marketing Executive at Eurocom CI

Ramya Sehmi

Ramya Sehmi is a Marketing Executive at Eurocom CI Ltd, a UK-based DBS umbrella body registered with the Disclosure and Barring Service. Holding a Master's in Management, Ramya leads content strategy and creation at Eurocom CI, working closely with the compliance team to ensure all published guidance reflects current DBS legislation and Home Office standards. Her work focuses on making complex background screening and safeguarding requirements clear and accessible for employers, HR professionals, and individuals navigating the DBS process.